Skip to Main content
My Sister's Fault logo
Cart icon0

Your order

‌
‌
‌
‌
Wait times are automatically estimated, but no worries, you will receive a txt when your order is ready for pick up.

My Sister's Fault

You can only place scheduled delivery orders.

My Sister's Fault

Special Orders (3 to 7 days required)

Popular Items

Combo Mini Cubano

$7.99

Half Sandwich, 1 Empanada and 1 mini soda included

Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)

Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)

$16.00

Rice of the day served with slowly cooked pork served a little lettuce and tomato. (Sometimes with sweet plantains or bread, depends on the rice of the day)

Empanadas & Rice Platter (your choice of empanadas)

Empanadas & Rice Platter (your choice of empanadas)

$12.75+

10 oz of rice served with your favorite empanadas!!! You can pick from the preset menu or pick your 3 and leave a comment.

My Sister's Fault

Hot Sauces & Dipping's

Mami's Hot Vinegar (2oz)

$0.25

Sweet Chilli Sauce (recommended) (2oz)

$0.25

Green & Red Hot Sauce (Spicy) (2oz)

$0.25

Mayo Ketchup (2oz)

$0.50

Cheddar Cheese Sauce (2oz)

$0.50

Sour Cream (2oz)

$0.50

Guava Jelly (2oz)

$0.50

BBQ Sauce (2oz)

$0.50

Mustard (2oz)

$0.25

12 oz Bottle Mami's Hot Vinegar (made in house)

$10.00Out of stock

Our mom's recipe of spicy yet gentle vinegar base hot liquid goodness now available by the bottle, perfect to marinate or simple put on your empanadas.

Empanadas & Appetizers

Mixed Box of Empanadas

Mixed Box of Empanadas

$13.00

Inludes 1 beef, 1 chalupa, 1 chicken, 1 cheesedog, 1 pizza) NOT EXCHANGABLE

Beef Empanada

Beef Empanada

$3.00

Savory Ground Beef (91/8) with a hint of potato. Please order hot sauces if needed under the "sauces" section. We recommend Mami's Sauce with it!

Chicken & Cheese Empanada

Chicken & Cheese Empanada

$3.00

Shredded Chicken Breast with mozarella cheese and a hint of potato. Please order side of hot sauce under hot sauce section. We recommend chicken empanadas with BBQ Sauce!!!!

CHICKEN CHALUPA

CHICKEN CHALUPA

$3.50

Chicken and cheese empanada filled with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese.

BEEF CHALUPA

Our version of a chalupa is on a empanada filled with beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese...

Special Instructions
BEEF CHALUPA

BEEF CHALUPA

$3.50

Our version of a chalupa is on a empanada filled with beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese...

Veggie & Cheese Empanada

$3.50

Caramelized Onions, Mushrooms & Spinach with a homemade Parmesan and Mozarella cheese Sauce

Pionono Empanada

Pionono Empanada

$4.25

Ground Beef, Sweet Plantain & Cream Cheese. The empanada that best describe the sisters with the sweet & savory flavor!

Cheesedog Empanada

$3.00

Made with 100% BEEF HOT DOG and American cheese deep fried to perfection is our version if pig in a blanket!

Mini Nutella Empanadas

$9.00

5 count of mini Nutella empanadas dusted with powder sugar. Perfect to share or to satisfy that sweet tooth at the end of your meal.

Pizza Empanada

$3.75

Mozarella Cheese & Sauce (imported)

Side of Sweet Plantains (maduros)

$3.00+

ripe sweet plantains (gluten friendly)

Dominican Fried Cheese (10)

Dominican Fried Cheese (10)

$5.99

10 Count Dominican Fried Cheese served with a side of Guava Jelly

Bread Toasts/ Tostadas de Pan (8)

$2.99

8 small pieces of pan sobao toasted.

Chicharrones/ Pork Rings (Goya)

$2.99

Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)

$3.99

Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread sold by the pound.

Plantain Chips (Goya) (G/F)

$2.99

Large Bag of Goya Plantain Chips

Sorullos- Deep Fried Corn Meal

$3.00+Out of stock

Deep Fried Corn meal filled with cheese - Imported from Puerto Rico

New!!! YUCA BALLS w/ Cheese

$8.00

6 count of Yuca Balls (cassava balls) filled with cheese served with a side of guava jelly

NEW!!! Taste of my island platter

$17.50Out of stock

Includes 1 beef chalupa 3 yuca balls 6 pork bites 6oz rice 2 slices of bread 3 sweet plantains 1 guava jelly 1 mayo ketchup NO SUBSTITUTIONS

Empanada BUNDLES

Order from this menu when ordering more than one empanada of the same kind. NO MIX & MATCH NO SUBSTITUTION.

BEEF EMPANADAS BUNDLE

$8.50+

CHICKEN EMPANADAS BUNDLE

$8.50+

CONTAINS MOZARELLA CHEESE

CHICKEN CHALUPAS BUNDLE

$10.50+

BEEF CHALUPAS BUNDLE

$10.50+

VEGGIE EMPANADAS BUNDLES

$11.00+

PIZZA EMPANADAS BUNDLES

$10.75+

BUNDLE PIONONO - 3 COUNT

$12.00

BUNDLE CHEESEDOG - 3 COUNT

$8.50

Empanada "Cake" (8 Chickn & 8 Beef)

$50.00

Rice & Platters of the Day

Our rice and menu changes daily.

Side of Rice of the Day: Arroz con Gandules/Pigeon Peas Rice

$5.00+

Please keep in mind our rice changes daily.

Goulash 'Angie's Style' (Coditos)

$8.00+

9oz of goulash served with 2 pieces of fresh bread. Our Goulash is made with 100% ground beef, tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan and our secret ingredient cream cheese!!!!

Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)

Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)

$16.00

Rice of the day served with slowly cooked pork served a little lettuce and tomato. (Sometimes with sweet plantains or bread, depends on the rice of the day)

Empanadas & Rice Platter (your choice of empanadas)

Empanadas & Rice Platter (your choice of empanadas)

$12.75+

10 oz of rice served with your favorite empanadas!!! You can pick from the preset menu or pick your 3 and leave a comment.

Eggs, Plantains & Avocado Served with Rice of the Day Platter

$12.00

2 FRIED EGGS (please leave in the comments how will you like your eggs cooked) served with rice of the day, 3 sweet plantains and avocado.

Side of Sweet Plantains (maduros)

$3.00+

ripe sweet plantains (gluten friendly)

Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)

$3.99

Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread sold by the pound.

Side of Pork (Pernil)

$7.00+

Our Caribbean flavored slowly cooked Pork shoulder served the size of your choice (includes fatty tissue) if prefer more or less fat please leave in the comments.

Plantain Chips (Goya) (G/F)

$2.99

Large Bag of Goya Plantain Chips

Breakfast ALL Day

Egg & Cheese Sandwich #1

$4.99+

2 fried eggs and your choice of cheese

BACON, EGG & CHEESE #2

$6.99+

2 Fried Eggs, bacon, your choice of cheese served in bread, wrap or platter

HAM, EGG & CHEESE #3

$6.99+

2 Fried Eggs, Ham, your choice of cheese served in bread, wrap or platter

Bacon Pounder #4

$12.00+

3 Eggs Scrambled, 3 american cheese and the rest is BACON!!!! (about 10-12 slices) Served in your choice of bread or wrap, platter

Criollo Sandwich #5

$7.99+

2 fried eggs, Ham, American, Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato and Ketchup served in your choice of

Kielbasa, Egg & Cheese #6

$6.99+

2 eggs, beef kielbasa and your choice of cheese.

Turkey, Avo, Jalapeno & Bacon #7

$11.99+

Fried Eggs, Turkey, Muenster Cheese, Avocados, Jalapenos, Bacon and May

Dominican Mamma Platter #8

$12.00+

Pork, Salami, Dominican Cheese, eggs, sweet plantain and avocados

Salami & Dominican Cheese Sandwich #9

$10.00+

2 eggs, dominican cheese, domincan salami and mayo ketchup sauce

Jamming Bacon Burrito #10

$5.45+

2 scrambled eggs, 3 slices of bacon, 6 tater tots and cheese wrapped in a burrito. choose between low carb or regular.

Veggie, Egg & Cheese Burrito #11

$5.45+

2 scrambled eggs, green peppers, onion & tomato 6 tater tots and cheese.

Turkey, Egg & Cheese #12

$6.95+

Sliced Turkey Breast, eggs and cheese served with your choice of bread or low carb

Gary's Burrito #14

$12.00+

Scrambled Eggs, Shredded Pork, Bacon, Avocado, Jalapeno, Sweet Pickle & American Cheese created by one of our favorite customers Gary!

Ham & Cheese Melt #15

$5.95

Simple! American Cheese and Ham grilled in a sobao bread sandwich. Please leave a comment if prefer low carb.

Ava's Grilled Cheese #16

$4.50

4 slices of American served in Pan Sobao, melted (please leave a comment if prefer low carb bread)

BLT SANDWICH #28

$10.00+

8 slices of bacon, Lettuce & Tomato served in our sweet and soft pan sobao or low carb. (it does not include mayo or any other condiments) Please choose extra condiments in the menu below.

Nutella SANDWICH

$6.75

Nutella Grilled in Pan Sobao (Bread) dusted with Powder Sugar

Traditional Breakfast

$9.45+

This is our typical Puerto Rican Breakfast. 3 eggs scrambled with chopped ham, onions, green peppers & tomato

Cubanos & More Specialties

Cubano Controversial #18

$12.00+

Our version of a Cubano sandwich and why is controversial? Because we served it in our sweet & soft made in house sobao bread, Ham, Swiss, Sweet Pickles and Mustard.

Sister's Cubano #19

$12.00+

Slowly Cooked Pork, Ham, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Mustard, Mayo, Ketchup and potato sticks served in a sandwich.

Tripleta Classica #20

$12.00+

Chopped Pastrami, Ham & Pork, lettuce, cheddar, mayo, ketchup and potato sticks in a 6 inch Sandwich made with our sweet & soft bread.

Pastrami Lover's #21

$12.00+

Chopped Pastrami served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo and Swiss.

Turkey & Bacon #22

$11.00+

Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo.

Dominican Mamma Platter #8

$12.00+

Pork, Salami, Dominican Cheese, eggs, sweet plantain and avocados

Phillip Pastrami #23

$12.00+

Chopped Pastrami, Green Peppers, Onions, Muensters Cheese, Mayo and Jalapenos

Sandwich de Pernil (Pork Shoulder) #24

$12.00+

Our Slowly Cooked Pork served with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Ketchup and Swiss.

BBQ Pulled Pork #25

$12.00+Out of stock

Our Sweet and Tangy BBQ Pulled Pork is served with Sweet Pickles in our soft & sweet pan sobao. Don't want soggy bread? we can serve it on the side for you if request it.

Pork Swiss & Muenster Melt #26

$10.00

2 slices of swiss and 2 slices of muenster served with our slowly cooked pork.

Low Carb Cubano with Eggs Platter #27

$12.00+

2 fried eggs, served with our slowly cooked pork, ham, swiss, mustard, sweet pickles and jalapenos

BLT SANDWICH #28

$10.00+

8 slices of bacon, Lettuce & Tomato served in our sweet and soft pan sobao or low carb. (it does not include mayo or any other condiments) Please choose extra condiments in the menu below.

Mozarella Crusted Pork Quesadilla

$10.00

Choose between Low Carb or Reg Wrap. Made with Mozarella Cheese & Shredded Pork with a side of lettuce, tomato and sour cream. You can customize it your way !!!

Sweets & Desserts

Ben & Jenn Chocolate Lovers Cake

$4.99

9" Whole Reese's Cake

$45.00

Gluten Free and Sugar Free Dessserts

All of our sugar free & gluten free products are made with almond flour, coconut flour, dairy & some form of nuts.

GF SF Vanilla Tres Leches

$3.75

GF SF Chocolate Lover's Cake

$4.50

All of our Gluten Free & Sugar Free Products are made out of Coconut, Almond or dairy products unless otherwise specified pease ask about any potential allergies.

GF SF Double Glaze Donut

$3.50

All of our Gluten Free & Sugar Free Products are made out of Coconut, Almond or dairy products unless otherwise specified pease ask about any potential allergies.

GF SF Cinnamon Donut

$3.00

All of our Gluten Free & Sugar Free Products are made out of Coconut, Almond or dairy products unless otherwise specified pease ask about any potential allergies.

SALE- PICK 4 Different GF & SF Desserts

$12.00

Choose one of EACH or we can randomly pick for you! please leave a comment. (This deal can only be use when choosing 4 different items, not the same) bake goods may contain with nut & coconut flour

Combo Meals

Combo Mini BACON, EGG & CHEESE

$7.50

Half Sandwich, 1 Empanada and 1 mini soda included

Combo Mini Salami Sandwich

$7.99

Half Sandwich, 1 Empanada and 1 mini soda included

Combo Mini Turkey & Bacon

$7.99

Half Sandwich, 1 Empanada and 1 mini soda included

Combo Mini Cubano

$7.99

Half Sandwich, 1 Empanada and 1 mini soda included

Kids Meal

Mini Grilled Cheese, Side of Rice and one empanada

$5.25

Mini Ham & Cheese Melt, Side of Rice & Empanada

$6.25

Mini Nutella Sandwich, Side of Rice, One Empanada

$6.25

Mini Egg & Cheese Sandwich. side of rice, one empanada

$5.25

Pork, Rice & Empanada

$7.25

4oz Small rice 4oz side of pork 1 empanada

Drinks, Coffees & Teas

My Sisters Fault Coffee HOT (until 2pm)

$3.00

Made with Whole Milk We add Condensed Milk and a hint of cinnamon.

My Sister's Fault Coffee ICED

$3.25

Made with Whole Milk We ADD Condensed Milk and a hint of cinnamon.

Passion Fruit Goya Juice 33oz

$4.00

Pineapple Goya Juice 33oz

$4.00

Malta Goya

$2.50

Aquafina Bottle Water

$1.50

Baja blast Mountain Dew

$1.50

Coke (can)

$1.50

Diet Coke (can)

$1.50

Pepsi (can)

$1.50

Tropi Cola (can)

$1.50

Tropi Coco (Coconut Soda)

$1.50

Sprite (can)

$1.50

Perrier Sparkling Water

$2.75Out of stock

Ginger Ale (can)

$1.50

Orange Soda (Can)

$1.50

Brisk Iced Tea (can)

$1.50

Pure Leaf Sweet Tea

$2.75Out of stock

Twist Lemonade (zero sugar limonada)

$2.50

Citrus Green Tea (sugar free)

$2.50

NesQuick Hot Chocolate

$3.00

NesQuick ICED Chocolate

$3.00

HOT TEA (variety)

$2.50+

We have a variety of hot teas earl gray with Milk is the top requested. Just leave a comment and we will serve to you if available.

Welch Juice (variety) 10oz

$1.50Out of stock

MSF T-Shirts (Double sided)

XS t-shirt

$20.00

Small T-shirt

$20.00

Medium Tshirts

$20.00

Large T-shirt

$20.00

X Large Tshirt

$20.00

2XL TShirts

$20.00

3XL T-shirts

$20.00Out of stock

Special Orders (3 to 7 days required)

Food Catering

Family Dinner Pork, Rice and Pan Sobao

$80.00

Slowly Cooked Pork Shoulder 5 pounds (inlcudes fat) Arroz con Gandules (Pigeon Peas Rice) 5 pounds. 1 Pound of Bread. Serves 8-10 guests

5 POUNDS BBQ Pulled Pork & 2 Pounds of Bread

$60.00

5 Pounds of our sweet and Tangy BBQ Pulled Pork. Includes a side of sweet pickles and 2 pounds of pan sobao Serves 8-10 guests *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 3 day notice*

Whole Angie's Style Chicken Lasagna & Pound of Bread

$65.00

*1 WEEK NOTICED REQUIRED** 1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with Chicken Breast, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *1 week notice required to order this item*

Whole Angie's Style Beef Lasagna & Pound of Bread

$65.00

1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with 100% Ground Beef, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests (1 week noticed required)

BUNDLE BEEF EMPANADAS - 12 COUNT

$30.00

BUNDLE CHICKEN EMPANADAS - 12 COUNT

$30.00

6 Pounds of Rice

$50.00

Arroz Con Gandules - Pigeon Peas Rice *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 2 day notice*

5 Pounds of Pork Shoulder

$45.00

2 DAY NOTICE

Family Order of Sweet Planatains

$18.00

Ripe Sweet Plantains

Dinner Rolls de Sobao Bread (next day pick up)

$3.99

7-10 count of Pan Sobao Dinner Rolls - 24 hour noticed required

Family Dinner Buttery Chicken Breast, Rice & Pound of Bread

$80.00Out of stock

5 Pounds of Thinly Sliced Buttery Chicken Breast 5 Pounds of Arroz con Gandules 1 pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 3 day notice*

Special Cake or Dessert Menu

Whole Cake 9'' (all the classics to choose from)

$50.00

The Starting price for this cake is $50. Extra customizations will be charged separately.

Tres Leches 9'' Pan

$17.00Out of stock

Our Tres Leches is SUPER MOIST! and is not sliceable. We recommend customers to taste our tres leches (by the cup) before ordering a whole one, It is delicious but different!!!!

Vanilla Flan 9''

$20.00Out of stock

9'' aluminun pan. Flip it over and let the caramel shine!

24 count Mini Quesitos & Mini Pastelillos (12 of each)

$35.00

Quesitos - Cream Cheese Puff Pastry. Pastelillos - Guava Puff Pastry. Both in bite sizes. *1 week notice required to order this item*

DOZEN MINI QUESITOS

$24.00

DOZEN MINI PASTELILLOS

$12.00

Cheesecake Tray Bite Size 20 count

$50.00

Variety of flavor cheesecakes in a bite size! 20 count *1 week notice required to order this item*

Build Your Own Cake (10) SLICES (next day pick up)

$45.99

10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! (this is a non diet item) and it looks like a whole cake! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it. NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER FOR TUESDAY MORNING

Dessert Party Tray 24 Count

$55.00

3 day notice required. A variety of bite size desserts. Perfect for gatherings. 24 count(variety is randomly choose) this is the simple version. For a more elegant version is an extra charge of $25

7'' Rum Cake (Large)

$15.00

Simple, Yet Delicious! Bundt Cake Style with Walnuts and lots of RUM!!!!

CANVAS CAKE DECORATING KIT

$50.00Out of stock

5 days notice required - choose between a 7'' or 9'' round cake (same price both cakes 9'' wider - 7'' taller) Pick 3 Colors of your choice.

My Sister's Fault Location and Ordering Hours
(302) 503-7446
10 Southwest Front Street, Milford, DE 19963
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 9AM
Order online
Facebook logo
This site is powered byToast logo
Terms of Service | Privacy Statement