My Sister's Fault
Food Menu After 6pm
Empanadas & Appetizers
- Side of Rice of the Day: White Rice & Pink Stewed Beans
RICE CHANGES DAILY PLEASE READ TODAYS RICE!
$5.50 - New Guava & Cream Cheese Empanada
Made with a flaky buttery dough filled with Philadelphia Cream Cheese and Guava paste
$3.75 - BEEF EMPANADA
Savory Ground Beef (91/8) with a hint of potato. Please order hot sauces if needed under the "sauces" section. We recommend Mami's Sauce with it!
$3.30 - Chicken & Cheese Empanada
Shredded Chicken Breast with mozzarella & cream cheese and a hint of potato. Please order side of hot sauce under hot sauce section. We recommend chicken empanadas with BBQ Sauce or the sweet chilli.
$3.30 - Cheesedog Empanada
Made with 100% BEEF HOT DOG and American cheese deep fried to perfection is our version if pig in a blanket!
$3.30 - Pionono Empanada
Ground Beef, Sweet Plantain & Cream Cheese. The empanada that best describe the sisters with the sweet & savory flavor!
$4.50 - Veggie & Cheese Empanada
Caramelized Onions, Mushrooms & Spinach with a homemade Parmesan and Mozarella cheese Sauce
$4.00 - BEEF CHALUPA EMPANADA
Our version of a chalupa is on a empanada filled with beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese...
$4.00 - CHICKEN CHALUPA EMPANADA
Chicken and cheese empanada filled with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese.
$4.00 - Side of Sweet Plantains (maduros)
ripe sweet plantains (gluten friendly)
$3.25 - Mini Nutella Empanadas
5 count of mini Nutella empanadas dusted with powder sugar. Perfect to share or to satisfy that sweet tooth at the end of your meal.
$9.00 - New!!! YUCA BALLS w/ Cheese
8 count of Yuca Balls (cassava balls) filled with cheese served with a side of guava jelly
$4.25 - Dominican Fried Cheese
10-12 Count Dominican Fried Cheese served with a side of Guava Jelly
$5.99 - Sauces & Dipping’s
Order side of sauces here to dip your empanadas! We recommend Sweet Chili for Chicken Mamis Vinegar for Beef and red & green if you like spicy!
$0.25 - Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)
Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread sold by the pound.
$4.50 - Chicharrones/ Pork Rings Bag (Goya)
Large Bag of Goya Pork Rings
$3.99 - Plantain Chips Bag (Goya) (G/F)
Large Bag of Goya Plantain Chips
$3.99 - Deep Fried Cheesecake (online)
Our fluffy Puerto Rican style cheesecake deep fried topped with your choice of caramel or chocolate sauce and dusted with cinnamon sugar!
$7.99
Platters & Rice of the Day
- Side of Rice of the Day: White Rice & Pink Stewed Beans
RICE CHANGES DAILY PLEASE READ TODAYS RICE!
$5.50 - Empanadas & Rice Platter (your choice of empanadas)
16 oz of rice served with your favorite empanadas!!! You can pick from the preset menu or pick your 3 and leave a comment. PICTURE DOESNT REPRESENT TODAY's RICE OF THE DAY.
$13.25 - Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)
Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread sold by the pound.
$4.50 - Sauces & Dipping’s
Order side of sauces here to dip your empanadas! We recommend Sweet Chili for Chicken Mamis Vinegar for Beef and red & green if you like spicy!
$0.25 - Side of Pork (Pernil)
Our Caribbean flavored slowly cooked Pork shoulder served the size of your choice (includes fatty tissue) if prefer more or less fat please leave in the comments.
$7.00OUT OF STOCK - Rice Platter & Pernil (Shredded Pork Shoulder)
Platter includes Rice of the day, Shredded Pork, Lettuce, Tomato and your choice of bread, sweet plantains or tostones!!!
$16.50
Sweets & Desserts
Sweets & Desserts
- 10 Slices Build Your Own Cake
10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! (this is a non diet item) and it looks like a whole cake! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it. NOT AVAILABLE TO ORDER FOR TUESDAY MORNING
$49.99 - 7" Rum Cake (simple)$15.00
- Cream Cheese Mallorca
A puerto rican style sweet & soft roll filled with cream cheese!
$5.00 - Guava Puff Pastry/ Pastelillo de Guayaba
Puffpastry filled with guava sauce
$2.00 - Quesito - Puff Pastry
Cream cheese filled puff pastry
$3.25 - Quesito ALMOND
puff pastry filled with cream cheese and almond paste... topped with shaved almond
$4.00 - Rum Cake$4.75
- Cheesecake -Top with berries -GF
Our Crustless Puerto Rican Style Cheesecake. Fluffy and delicious.
$4.65 - Cheesecake- Plain GF
Puerto Rican Style - Crustless Cheesecake. Gluten Free Contains Sugar. Special Price Online Only
$4.00 - Flan de Vanilla Slice -GF
Puerto Rican Style vanilla custard.
$4.75 - Flan Cream Cheese - GF$4.75
- Tres Leches D' UBE
Philippine Purple Sweet Potato Cake soaked in 3 different milks (including coconut milk)
$3.00 - Brownie M&M$4.75
- Chocolate Mousse Cake$4.75
- Cloud Cake de Orange & Raspberry$6.00
- Reese's Chocolate Cake$5.00
- Ben & Jenn Chocolate Lovers Cake$5.00
- Limoncello Strawberry Cake$5.00
- Limoncello Blueberry Cake$5.00
- Ding Dong Cake$5.00
- Pistachio Raspberry Cake$5.00
- Oreo Chocolate Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Strawberry Crunch Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Chocolate & Cannoli Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Nutella Lava Bundt Cake$4.75OUT OF STOCK
- Pumpkin Spice & Cream Cheese Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Tiramisu Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Biscoff Cheesecake Crunch Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
Sugar Free & Gluten Friendly Desserts
Gluten Friendly Desserts (contains sugar)
- Flan Cream Cheese - GF$4.75
- Flan de Vanilla Slice -GF
Puerto Rican Style vanilla custard.
$4.75 - Cheesecake- Plain GF
Puerto Rican Style - Crustless Cheesecake. Gluten Free Contains Sugar. Special Price Online Only
$4.00 - Cheesecake -Top with berries -GF
Our Crustless Puerto Rican Style Cheesecake. Fluffy and delicious.
$4.65
Drinks & Coffee
Drinks, Coffees & Teas
- ICED- My Sisters Fault Coffee
Made with Whole Milk We ADD Condensed Milk and a hint of cinnamon.
$3.25 - Malta Goya$3.00
- Aquafina Bottle Water$2.00
- Coke (can)$2.00
- Diet Coke (can)$2.00
- Pepsi (can)$2.00
- Sprite (can)$2.00
- NesQuick ICED Chocolate$3.50
- HOT TEA (variety)
We have a variety of hot teas earl gray with Milk is the top requested. Just leave a comment and we will serve to you if available.
$3.50 - Welch Juice (variety) 10oz$2.00
- Pure Leaf Sweet Tea$2.75OUT OF STOCK
- Perrier Sparkling Water$3.00
- Mountain Dew (Can)$2.00
- Guava Goya Juice 42oz$4.00
- Tropi Cola (can)$2.00
- Ginger Ale (can)$2.00
- Lipton Green Tea$3.00OUT OF STOCK
- Tamarind Goya Juice 33oz$4.00
- Guava Can Juice 42oz$4.00
- Twist Lemonade Sugar Free$3.00
- Pineapple Goya Juice 33oz$4.00
- Tropi Coco (Coconut Soda)$2.00OUT OF STOCK
- Passion Fruit Goya Juice 33oz$4.00
- Pure Leaf Extra Sweet Tea$2.75
- Baja blast Mtn Dew$2.00
Sauces & Dippings
Sauces & Dipping's
- Mami's Vinegar
Our made in house vinegar based hot juice! Perfect for your empanadas or even marinades.
$0.30 - Sweet Chilli$0.50
- Red & Green Hot Sauce$0.50
- Mayo Ketchup$0.50
- Sour Cream$0.50
- Cheddar Cheese Sauce (2oz)$0.50
- Guava Jelly (2oz)$0.50
- BBQ Sauce$0.50
- Mustard (2oz)$0.25
- Roasted Tomatoes & Jalapeño$0.50OUT OF STOCK
Merchant (t-Shirts Sale)
SALE “Hoodies , T-Shirts & Long Sleeves” (Copy)
Desserts Special Orders (4 days required)
Whole Cakes & Desserts
- Whole Cake 9'' Top Sellers
Cakes are non-customizable. We do not write on cakes. We do offer a free Happy Birthday Sign if requested.
$50.00 - Dessert Party Tray 24 Count
A variety of bite size desserts. Perfect for gatherings. 24 count(variety is randomly choose) this is the simple version. For a more elegant version is an extra charge of $25
$55.00 - 24 count Mini Quesitos & Mini Pastelillos (12 of each)
Quesitos - Cream Cheese Puff Pastry. Pastelillos - Guava Puff Pastry. Both in bite sizes. *1 week notice required to order this item*
$35.00 - Build Your Own Cake (10) SLICES (1 week required)
10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! (this is a non diet item) and it looks like a whole cake! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it.
$49.99 - Tres Leches 9''
Our Tres Leches is SUPER MOIST! and is not sliceable. We recommend customers to taste our tres leches (by the cup) before ordering a whole one, It is delicious but different!!!!
$17.00 - Vanilla Flan 9''
9'' aluminum pan. Flip it over and let the caramel shine!
$20.00 - DOZEN MINI QUESITOS
Our cream cheese filled puff pastry but mini versions of it!
$24.00 - DOZEN MINI Guava Puff Pastry
Our guava filled puff pastry but the mini version.
$12.00 - Virgin Coquito {DRINK}
Classic Puerto Rican drink made with coconut cream, coconut milk, cinnamon and cloves.
$20.00 - Cheesecake Tray Bite Size 20 count
Variety of flavor cheesecakes in a bite size! 20 count *1 week notice required to order this item*
$50.00 - 7'' Rum Cake (Large)
Simple, Yet Delicious! Bundt Cake Style with Walnuts and lots of RUM!!!!
$15.00OUT OF STOCK - 9” PRETZELESS SALAD Gluten Friendly & Sugar Free
Made with Crushed pecans instead of pretzels this Gluten friendly and sugar free dessert is our most popular dessert!
$30.00 - 9” Passion Fruit Cheesecake Topped with Berries Gluten Friendly & Sugar Friendly
Made with a GF crust and tangy passion fruit filling topped with berries.
$30.00 - 9” Tembleque / Coconut Custard
Our only Vegan, Dairy Free & Gluten Free dessert. Puerto Rican style coconut custard. Get it while is available this holiday season! Contains (cloves & cinnamon)
$20.00
Larger Food Orders (1 day required)
Large Food Orders
- Family Dinner Pork, Rice and Pan Sobao (serves 8-10)
Slowly Cooked Pork Shoulder 5 pounds (inlcudes fat) Arroz con Gandules (Pigeon Peas Rice) 5 pounds. 1 Pound of Bread. Serves 8-10 guests
$80.00 - Side of Rice of the Day
This rice is to be order from our 3 day notice menu. For todays rice please see under “Rice Of the day & platters menu at the top of this page”
- Side of Pork (Pernil)
Our Caribbean flavored slowly cooked Pork shoulder served the size of your choice (includes fatty tissue) if prefer more or less fat please leave in the comments.
$8.00 - Side of Sweet Plantains (maduros)
ripe sweet plantains (gluten friendly)
$3.25 - Pan Sobao (2 Loafs of Bread)
Our made in house Puerto Rican soft & sweet bread sold by the pound.
$4.50 - Dinner Rolls de Sobao Bread (8-10 count)
8-10 count of Pan Sobao Dinner Rolls - 24 hour noticed required
$3.99 - 5 POUNDS BBQ Pulled Pork & 2 Pounds of Bread
5 Pounds of our sweet and Tangy BBQ Pulled Pork. Includes a side of sweet pickles and 2 pounds of pan sobao Serves 8-10 guests *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 3 day notice*
$60.00 - Whole Angie's Style Beef Lasagna & Pound of Bread
1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with 100% Ground Beef, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests (1 week noticed required)
$65.00 - Whole Angie's Style Chicken Lasagna & Pound of Bread
*1 WEEK NOTICED REQUIRED** 1/2 Sheet Lasagna Pan made with Chicken Breast, Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan and our secret ingredient Cream Cheese! Includes 1 Pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *1 week notice required to order this item*
$65.00 - Family Dinner Buttery Chicken Breast, Rice & Pound of Bread (serves 8-10)
5 Pounds of Thinly Sliced Buttery Chicken Breast 5 Pounds of Arroz con Gandules 1 pound of Bread Serves 8-10 guests *Please be aware this menu requires minimum a 3 day notice*
$80.00
Empanada BUNDLES
- BEEF EMPANADA
Savory Ground Beef (91/8) with a hint of potato. Please order hot sauces if needed under the "sauces" section. We recommend Mami's Sauce with it!
$3.30 - BEEF CHALUPA EMPANADA
Our version of a chalupa is on a empanada filled with beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese...
$4.00 - Chicken & Cheese Empanada
Shredded Chicken Breast with mozzarella & cream cheese and a hint of potato. Please order side of hot sauce under hot sauce section. We recommend chicken empanadas with BBQ Sauce or the sweet chilli.
$3.30 - Veggie & Cheese Empanada
Caramelized Onions, Mushrooms & Spinach with a homemade Parmesan and Mozarella cheese Sauce
$4.00 - Cheesedog Empanada
Made with 100% BEEF HOT DOG and American cheese deep fried to perfection is our version if pig in a blanket!
$3.30 - Pionono Empanada
Ground Beef, Sweet Plantain & Cream Cheese. The empanada that best describe the sisters with the sweet & savory flavor!
$4.50 - CHICKEN CHALUPA EMPANADA
Chicken and cheese empanada filled with lettuce, tomato, sour cream and cheddar cheese.
$4.00